Anderson

4X2

an online poetry journal

  • Man's West Once

    by Susan Kay Anderson

    “Visions! omens! hallucinations! miracles! ecstasies, gone down the American river!”

    –Allen Ginsberg, “Howl”

     

    I.

    Fed by the Coloradans, I studied their ways, their trees,

    and what was written on them, what was left. Names, dates.

     

    They took me in, gave me Nescafe

    instead of an Americano to-go,

    Ramona’s hands arthritic

    would not straighten. Roy’s

    gigantic mitts

    which knew

    irrigation and barbed wire.

    milk-marinated elk steak

    instead of Nancy’s Yogurt.

     

    That summer, I was 22 and fresh

    out of college. I was given One Man’s West,

                                                                                       

    by David Lavender. A present from Ramona.

    Ramona was a summer babysitter for Little David.

     

    Ramona’s favorite book! She was mentioned,

    only under another name. She was

     

    David Lavender’s biggest fan—handed everyone

    copies of One Man’s West and told about Cy Orr,

     

    the cowboy with one eye, featured in the book,

    who heard her recite “Panhandle Cob”

     

    when she was in the second grade. After the program

    Old Cy said he knew Panhandle Cob

     

    and from then on they were friends

    and she took his photo at the Boar’s Nest—

     

    with a borrowed camera,

    he was on Old West treasure!

     

    She left her May Day basket

    on his porch after knocking.

     

    His shack perched on some rocks

    near the Bedrock Store, half alive

    and all alone, while maggots

    busily cleaned his empty socket.

    .

    She was so small when she was born,

    they did not name her,

    the youngest of eleven.

    She fit in a shoe box,

    set on the door of the oven,

    oiled and wrapped in cotton.

    Her father moved the family around

    in a covered wagon.

    Her father had a violin.

     

     

    I loved Roy. I loved Ramona. Loved

                                                                                                    their

     

    photo album.

    The cougars,

    dead,

    “Sweet Georgia Brown”

    on the player piano,

    played by Ramona—

     

    Their kitchen smelled of aspic and linoleum,

    failed cakes, bacon and eggs, and Delta’s cottonwood air

    of the old Council Tree

    and of the dinosaurs’ search for water—

    dry, dry, as Captain John Smith’s Rock House

    we drove to see—Ramona’s favorite place—

    and her emerald eyes were startling.

     

    From the second floor window of the old homestead

    now in town, Grand Mesa’s outline loomed from across

    Delta’s moonscape of sage and islands of alfalfa.

     

     

    Roy wanted to see The Natural

    at the Delta Drive-In.  He fell asleep

    just as it got interesting.  But he sure knew

     

    beautiful bodies

    all in a row at the feet of the hunters

    who tracked them on horseback

    ball games. He was a great pitcher

    and two-stepper. He was the one

    you wanted on the dance floor! They hated Reagan

    and I was surprised. I was “the nice girl from Germany”

    even though I said that was my mom, not me.

    Roy was their guide

    in the West Elk Mountains.

     

    Their dog, Babe, an ancient lab

    with weeping eyes. Ramona loved The Rubiyat  

     

    with dogs—

    visitors from Chicago

    in the 60s and 70s

    when there were still

    so many.

     

    by Omar Khayam, “the moving finger writes

    and having writ, moves on...”

    Packing them in

    and out

    of the wilderness.

    That was Roy,

    his extra income!

    Being a plumber,

    times were rough.

    Six mouths to feed.

    I thought:

    this is the West

    I have escaped

    to somewhere else.

     

    There was no argument

    no protest, with One Man’s West

    in my possession

    up at Lone Cone. I wanted

    answers

    to my questions,

    who traps whom?

    Would I be forever left

    wading through the doghair aspens

    growing back so thick

    after a clear cut

    sticking to my jeans

    holding me back

    impossible to pass.

                                        Who is able to hear

                                         a cloud floating?

     

    Hank wrote a Dear John letter

    only saying:

                                        Whenever he appeared

                                        with his trusty band,

                                        terror reined among

                                        the cattle, and wrath

                                        and despair among

                                        their owners.

                                                                                                    Dear Susan,

    I am happy

    with someone else. 

    She does her nails,

    they are painted

    fancy,

    sharp. 

    We sleep together

    on a mattress on the floor.

    There is no home

    for you

    to come home to.

    Stay in Colorado.

     

                                        Old Lobo was a giant among wolves,

                                        and was cunning and strong in proportion

                                        to his size.  His voice at night was well-known

                                        and easily distinguished from his fellows.

    Ramona said:

    “Tell him to have at it.”

    when I asked for advice

    about Hank.

               

                                        Wild animals

                                        become scapegoats for our own fears.

    What did I have to fear?

    The light stayed the same. 

    The city pool glistened.

    Work went well

    and it was

    past.

    It was past

    time to go.

     

                                        An ordinary wolf might howl

                                        half the night about the herdsman’s

                                        bivouac without attracting more

                                        than a passing notice, but when

                                        the deep roar of the old king came booming

                                        down the canyon, the watcher bestirred himself

                                        and prepared to learn in the morning

                                        that fresh and serious inroads

                                        had been made among the herds.

     

     I was afraid

    of the wolf

    at the door

    suddenly appearing

     

                                        It will be seen, then that these wolves

                                        were thoroughly well-known to the cowboys

                                        and shepherds.

    my future

    wanting in

                                        How many of us have ever got to know

                                        a wild animal? 

    begging me to feed it

    more

    or it would take what

    it wanted

    all along.

    ***

    Our malamute was not a toy

    but looked like one

    when he was little

    up in Nome.

                                        I do not mean merely to meet with one once

                                        or twice, or to have one in a cage, but to really

                                        know it for a long time while it is wild,

                                        and get insight into its life and history.

     

    I remember him running across

    the tundra

    hitched to a saucer

    pulling Suzanne Chung

    into the nowhere

    of Anvil Mountain

    from Chicken Hill.

     

                                        The trouble usually is to know one creature

                                        from his fellow. One fox or crow is so much

                                        like another that we cannot be sure that it really

                                        is the same next time we meet. 

     

    How did he get back?

     

                                        But once in awhile there arises an animal who is stronger

                                        or wiser than his fellow, who becomes a great leader,

                                        who is, as we would say, a genius, and if he is bigger

                                        or has some mark by which men can know him,

                                        he soon becomes famous in his country, and

                                        shows us that the life of a wild animal may be far

                                        more interesting and exciting than that of many human

    How smart was she

    to fall off, letting go

    of the plastic handles!        

                           

                                        beings

    One hundred and fifty years ago

    the Great Plains was the richest place on Earth

    teeming with fauna

    quickly silenced.

                                        Of this class were Courtrand, the bob-tailed

                                        wolf that terrorized the whole city of Paris

                                        for about ten years in the beginning of the

                                        fourteenth century;

    .

    ***

    I was never afraid

    of tornadoes. I trained myself

    by lying in ditches in Missouri

    just in case one would come—

    and in Nome, practicing closing my mouth

    and only breathing through

    my nose

    my babysitter said our lungs

    could freeze, otherwise

                                        Clubfoot; the lame grizzly bear that in two years

                                        ruined all the hog-raisers, and drove half the farmers

                                        out of business in the upper Sacramento Valley;

    snuggling inside

                                        Lobo, the king-wolf of New Mexico,

                                        that killed a cow

                                        every day for five years, and the

    my wolverine ruff

     

                                        Soehnee panther that in less than two years killed nearly

                                        three hundred human beings—and such also was Silverspot.

    on the hood

    of my parka.

     

                                        They are successful hunters not farmers.

     

    II.

                                        It was a very peculiar sensation of discomfort, or frustration;

                                        my whole body moved and stretched with unusual lightness

                                        and strength. My arms and legs itched. My shoulders seemed

                                        to swell; the muscles in my back and neck made me feel like pushing,

                                        or rubbing, against trees. I felt I could demolish a wall by ramming it.

     

    Shumagin, our husky,

    could not stand it for long—the wait in the car

    made him snappy.

    Where is my West?

    How do I find it?

    Once, we got to the beach,

    and let him loose,

    he got into a fight

    with another dog

    at the party.

                                        I was there by myself. 

                                        If something harmful

                                        was going to happen to me,

                                        there was no one there to help me. 

                                        I wanted to run away.

     

    I saw how the other dog, Muchuck,

    had Shumagin’s eye

    in his mouth

    and seemed to be pulling,

    pulling.  I saw the optic nerve,

    and some adults pouring beer

    over them to stop their fighting.  It dripped,

    sliding to the gravel bar

    in full view of the gold dredge.

    Ribs from an abandoned

    Quonset hut, frowning. It will be

    wildly cold. 

     

     

     

     

     

    ***

    So many times

    I imagined my other life.

    A life of glass surfaces.

    Easy to polish,

     a cinch to wipe clean.

     

                                        I had an alarming sensation

                                         of indecision,

                                         of not knowing what to do.

     

                                        A flood of thoughts

                                        rushed into my mind,

                                         flashing

                                        with extraordinary speed. 

                                       

                                        I noticed

                                        they were rather strange thoughts;

                                        that is, they were

                                        strange in the sense

                                        that they seemed to come

                                        in a different way

                                        than ordinary thoughts. 

     

    I read about an animal

    quite unlike any other.

    The information is startling

    so familiar.

    Who is

     this strange animal?

     

                                        I am familiar

                                        with the way I think. 

                                        My thoughts

                                        have a definite order

                                        that is my own,

                                        and any deviation

                                        is noticeable.

     

    In Nevada,

    our beautiful malamute

    was shot

    by a neighbor.

    “He was such a nuisance,”

    they said, “never tied up,

    always roaming.”

     

                                        One of the alien thoughts

                                        was about a statement

                                        made by an author. 

                                        It was,

                                        I vaguely remember,

                                        more like a voice,

                                        or something said

                                        somewhere

                                        in the background. 

                                        It happened so fast

                                        that it startled me.

    The wolf is imaginary.

    The real one howls

    for home

    for a river

    An American river.

     

                                        I suddenly remembered

                                        it was Alfred Kroeber. 

    Our world

    known only in photo albums?

     

                                        Then another alien thought

                                        popped up and “said”

                                        that it was not Kroeber,

                                        but Georg Simmel,

                                        who had made the statement.

    How

    to win

    an argument

    against a gun?

                                        I insisted it was Kroeber,

                                        and the next

                                        thing I knew

    Are they howling

    or do they

    yelp?

     

                                        I was in the midst

                                        of an argument

                                        with myself. 

                                        And had

                                        forgotten about my feeling

                                        of being doomed.

     

    III.

     

    We were taught to love everybody.

     

    All the girls               who have flower-names                  dance along together,

    and those who have not                                          go together also. 

     

    Our fathers

    and mothers and grandfathers and grandmothers

    make a place for us

    where we can dance.                        Each one

    gathers the flower she was named for,

     

    and then

    all weave them into wreaths and crowns and scarfs

    and dress up in them.

     

    Some girls are named for rocks                 and are called rock-girls,

    and they find some pretty rocks which they carry; each one

    such a rock as she is named for,                or whatever she is named for.

    If she cannot,                        she can take a branch of sage-brush,

    or a bunch of rye-grass,                 

    which have no flower.

     

                They all go marching along,                                  

    each girl in turn singing of herself;

    but she is not a girl anymore--she is a flower singing.

     

     

     

     

    Notes:

     

    This title comes from a play on words from the book, One Man’s West, by David Lavender, 1943, 1956, 2007. University of Nebraska, Lincoln.

     

    Ideas in italics in Part I are found in Barry Lopez’s, Of Wolves And Men, 1978, Scribner & Sons, New York. The italics also contain material found in Ernest Seton Thomas’ Animals I Have Known, 1898, Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York.

     

    The italics in Part II are found in Carlos Casteneda’s The Teachings of Don Juan, A Yaqui Way of Knowledge, 1968.  University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, California.

     

    Part III is found in Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins’:  Life Among The Piutes:  Their Wrongs And Claims, 1883, G.P. Putnam’s Sons, New York; 1969, Chalfant Press, Inc., Sierra Media, Inc., Bishop, California.

Poet's Statement: This poem was written for Justin Hocking’s Wilderness Writing course at Eastern Oregon University in 2016 when I was studying for my M.F.A. in Poetry. I got a chance to revisit strong influences in my life and memories of growing up in Nome, Alaska, Schurz, Nevada, and working in Delta, Colorado as an archeological technician one summer for the Forest Service. These are themes I write about all the time, yet Hocking elicited a unique way of untangling and addressing complex issues in the West and wanted us to take a look at the state of wolves in the West. Our readings led me back to the wild territory of my youth. Speaking with writer and teacher, Megan Kruse, about another job I had in Maupin, Oregon, for the Bureau of Land Management also led me to write "Man's West Once." Kruse made me realize my love for small places was also her own because she listened so intently to my stories and knew my feelings of isolation and wonderment. Her attitude encouraged me to go forward with this particular collage. "Man's West Once" is dedicated to the memory of Tom Clark.

Bio: Susan Kay Anderson, 2010 National Poetry Series Finalist, has an M.F.A. in Creative Writing from Eastern Oregon University. Anderson was the poetry editor of Big Talk, a free publication in the early 1980s featuring Pacific Northwest punk bands. Her poems, essays, stories, and interviews can be found in Beat Scene, BlazeVOX Journal Spring 2016, Concis, Caliban Online, Guernica, Honolulu Civil Beat, Oregon East, Prairie Schooner, and Tom Clark Beyond The Pale. She lives in Eugene, Oregon.